Why does offside exist

What was once "4-opponents" has become "3-opponents" and finally "2-opponents" successively. There aren't many references in the article however, which kills the impact of the article. Probably the best source on the matter however is FIFA. Here's an excerpt from FIFA. Original offside rule The offside rule formed part of the original rules in but it was a far remove from the law as we know it today.

Any attacking player ahead of the ball was deemed to be offside - meaning early tactical systems featured as many as eight forwards, as the only means of advancing the ball was by dribbling or scrimmaging as in rugby. In the late s, the FA made the momentous decision to adopt the three-player rule, where an attacker would be called offside if positioned in front of the third-last defender.

Now the passing game could develop. Despite the unification of the rules and the creation of the FA in , disputes, largely involving Sheffield clubs who had announced their own set of ideas in , persisted into the late s. Then, as today, a three-quarters majority was needed for a proposal to be passed. All of us who have played and love the sport known as soccer in the US have misgivings about the offside rule. Many have argued to eliminate it altogether.

Those in favor of keeping the rule intact use the "poaching" argument which, to a certain extent has validity. But it is not necessary to eliminate the rule. A modification is all that is needed. Instead of calling offside every time the tip of an attacker's foot is ahead of the second last defender, the rule should be invoked only when the attacking player's entire body is clearly and unequivically ahead of the second last defender. That takes care of poaching.

In addition, the rule should not be invoked when all play is inside the box because, by definition, there is no poaching and the defense has had a full opportunity to defend. It makes no sense when, for instance, defenders and attackers are inside the small box fighting for the ball and offside is call.

Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more.

Why was offside introduced, and are there reasons for keeping it? Ask Question. Asked 9 years, 2 months ago. Active 3 years, 2 months ago. Viewed 40k times. Periodically, plans are mooted, but invariably fail. So, what are its origins, and why have all calls to scrap it been resisted? Improve this question.

Community Bot 1. James Wiseman James Wiseman 1 1 gold badge 2 2 silver badges 7 7 bronze badges. I'm not sure such a hypothetical is constructive, but I'm withholding a vote to close at the moment as I'm still undecided. I anticipated it might subject to those sorts of questions. Maybe "why isn't the football offside rule scrapped?

Have you noticed there is no offsides in basketball, and yet players do not just stand in front of the basket? A player was considered offside unless three players of the opposing side are in front of him includes goalkeeper. So in the above diagram, the player with the ball is considered offside because only two players are in front of him. The offside rule was changed in A player was considered offside unless two players of the opposing team are in front of him includes goalkeeper.

So in the above diagram, the player with the ball is NOT considered offside because two players are in front of him. The offside rule was changed again in A player is onside if he is level with the second-to-last player of the opposing team includes goalkeeper. If your answer to either of the above is yes, then ActiveSG Football Academy is the place for you to be at. Led by former Singapore international Aleksandar Duric, and five head coaches with experience from the highest level of football in Singapore: Richard Bok, Robin Chitrakar, Hyrizan Jufri, Mohamad Hairil Amin, Isa Halim, and Steven Tan, ActiveSG Football Academy has a holistic football programme designed to build character and impart the right skills while encouraging trainees to pursue their sporting passion with the right attitude.

To find out more or sign up for the academy, visit this link here. Understanding the offside rule. Share Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Email. Why do offsides even exist? The offside rule promotes gameplay that is systematically built up through a series of delightful manoeuvres like dribbling and short passes to the other end of the field, letting tactics shine and resulting in the game becoming more enjoyable to watch.

Why are offsides controversial? The offside rule is considered controversial because the modern game still utilises human referees, so there is always room for human error. And when play is stopped because an offside is called wrongly, it results in a missed opportunity for a team who was actually in a legitimate goal scoring position. The offside rule explained Here is the offside rule explained in 3 easy points.

That is if the player is involved in active play through any of the following conditions: Interfering with Play a Interfering with play Touching the ball with any part of your body when you are in an offside position.