Why does water siphon

To do this, maintain suction and carefully crimp the hose or use your thumb as a stopper. Now drop the end of the hose into the other container and release. Liquid should start traveling from the source container to the new one. Be sure to keep an eye on your source liquid and make sure the hose stays fully submerged, otherwise you'll end up with bubbles.

When you need to stop, lift the new container and hose higher than your source container. Then, remove the hose and let the excess fluid in the hose drain back into the source. Even though siphons have been used for thousands of years, modern scientists are still arguing about exactly which forces make siphons work.

For much of scientific history, scientists have believed that siphons work because of the force of atmospheric pressure. A basic siphon consists of a tube in a larger container that goes up over a hump the edge of the container to empty out into a container at a lower level. When liquid is sucked through the tube over the hump and begins to empty into the other container, a decrease in atmospheric pressure is caused at the highest point in the tube where it passes over the hump.

This decrease results in the atmospheric pressure on the surface of the liquid pushing liquid up into the tube toward the area of lower pressure.

While the atmospheric pressure theory seems to make sense, some scientists noted that it requires the presence of air. When tested in a vacuum , a siphon still worked, so it seemed that some other force must also be at work. More recently, scientists who have studied siphons have theorized that the key force is gravity. When liquid is sucked up the tube and over the hump, the force of gravity continues to pull the liquid through the tube.

This theory relies upon liquid cohesion, which means a continuous chain of cohesive bonds must exist in the liquid. Some scientists refer to this as the chain model, because you can think of the water like a chain being pulled through the tube instead of a liquid.

When you begin to pull the chain through the tube and over the hump, gravity will take over and continue to pull the entire length of the chain through the tube. Unfortunately, most liquids don't necessarily have strong cohesive bonds to make them act this way. Other scientists have created flying droplet siphons and carbon dioxide gas siphons that feature gas bubbles that exist between liquid molecules. It may be the case that atmospheric pressure , gravity, and liquid cohesion all work together to make siphons work the way they do.

Scientists will continue to study siphons to figure out once and for all how they work. Maybe you could grow up to be the scientist who solves the mystery! Isn't science fascinating? Find a few friends and family members to help you check out the following activities:. How about this one, sam? Hi, Caleb! Thanks for stopping by Wonderopolis! Which experiment are you referring to? We always recommend you having an adult with you when doing any type of experiment.

Have fun! Hi, Wonder Friend! We're sorry to hear that. Unfortunately, sometimes the videos are blocked by you school or organization.

Luckily, most of the information is in the Wonder itself so you're not missing out! Hi, Joe! Great question! Thanks for checking back, Jace! We're glad you had fun exploring the suggested Wonder. Unfortunately, we don't have that exact Wonder question. You can also submit your question to the Wonder Bank. All the Wonders are user submitted questions. We are undergoing some spring clearing site maintenance and need to temporarily disable the commenting feature. Thanks for your patience.

Drag a word to its definition. You have answered 0 of 3 questions correctly and your score is:. Want to add a little wonder to your website? Help spread the wonder of families learning together. We sent you SMS, for complete subscription please reply. Follow Twitter Instagram Facebook. Hughes, Stephen W. Physics Education, 45 2 , pp. Hughes exposed a serious error in dictionary definitions of "siphon", especiaially The Oxford English Dictionary definition: "A pipe or tube of glass, metal, or other material, bent so that one leg is longer than the other, and used for drawing off liquids by means of atmospheric pressure, which forces the liquid up the shorter leg and over the bend in the pipe.

But Hughes went on to propose cohesion and the "chain model" as the reason for siphon flow, ignoring the role of liquid pressure gradients. This chain model was refuted. See: Siphons, Revisited. Alex Richert and P. Binder, University of Hawaii at Hilo. The Physics Teacher, Vol. Reverse siphon? Vittorio Zonca's mill.

From Dircks The chain model treats the siphon flow as due to different weights of liquid in the two siphon arms. If it were the weight in the arms of the U-tube that causes and sustains liquid flow, then this hypothetical reverse siphon Fig. In fact this ought to allow a siphon to raise liquid from lower to higher levels. Vittorio Zonca , In his folio Novo Teatro di Machine et Edificii Padua, even proposed this idea as if it could be a useful device to lift water to drive the waterwheel or turbine of a mill.

Of course it could never work. In fact, this overbalanced siphon flows from left to right, from higher to lower level, just as an ordinary siphon does. The self-flowing flask of Robert Boyle. This is a digression, which the reader may skip. His clever example was a "self-flowing" flask Fig.

Why doesn't the greater weight of liquid in the flask force liquid to a higher level in the narrow tube so that it spills over and flows back into the flask. Perpetual motion! Add a small waterwheel just below the outlet and you could extract energy from the fluid flow. If there were any flow. Boyle's "self-flowing flask". The Hydrostatic Paradox. Even today there are people who see this picture of the flask and can't imagine why it doesn't work.

College students are often puzzled by it and at a loss to explain its fallacy. Zonca can be forgiven, for he lived at a time before the concept of force was well understood, and long before vector analysis of forces became a standard tool for analyzing physical systems. Today's physics students have no such excuse. To make the story short, the misconception here is to suppose that the entire weight of the liquid in the flask must be supported by the smaller weight of liquid in the tube.

This seems impossible, so one imagines the liquid must flow from left to right. But the weight of liquid is partly supported by the sloping walls of the flask. The wall exerts forces normal perpendicular to the wall, and these have upward components. The liquid in the flask is not entirely supported by weight of liquid on the right, but largely by the flask walls. Overlooking that fact leads to the apparent paradox.

The French mathematician Blaise Pascal illustrated it with a demonstration device, Pascal's Vases, which had glass flasks of various shapes and orientations connected to a common water reservoir.

The water level in each flask, whatever the flask's shape, was at the same height. Of course this is the essence of Aristotle's principle that "Water seeks its own level. Pascal's vases left. The pressures at A and B are the same. Showing forces due to the vessel walls right. Fluid pressure differences maintain the siphon flow. We have seen that it isn't the weight difference in the U-tube arms that initiates flow.

It is the pressure difference within the liquid that does that. It helps to realize a fundamental fact about hydrostatics.